analogue for the Joseph story, in which Joseph’s brothers pretend that the beloved one is dead, telling
Jacob, the father, that he has been killed by a wolf. Here Rumi is not told that the beloved one has
been killed by a group of his students, one of them his son. Both stories involve the central figure
living for years under a misconception about the person dearest to them. The Joseph story, of course,
resolves beautifully when Joseph, through his dream-interpreting skills, comes to be in charge of the
granaries of Egypt and then later reunites with his family.
Rumi is reunited with Shams in the poetry, and in his inmost core. Perhaps a conventional
religious community cannot contain the wild originality of a Shams Tabriz until it becomes embodied
in someone like Rumi, who can be a bridge between wild gnostic experience and more traditional
belief. This mysterious event comes on one of Rumi’s journeys in search of Shams. Suddenly,
walking a Damascus street, Rumi feels that he is their friendship, that he no longer needs to look for
Shams. Whatever miracle they were together, he is now in himself. Call off the search.
Rumi translator and biographer Franklin Lewis has done formidable research, and he sees the
story differently.2 He feels that Shams was not murdered, that he left on his own, perhaps so that
Rumi’s soul growth could move to another level. It is true that Shams was a mystic who demanded
movement, always more, of whatever came, always more blessings, more ecstatic praise. It must have
been strenuous to have been around Shams, almost impossible for some. Shams once said that if you
could lift up the Kaaba and take it out of the world, you would then see that what we all had been
praying to, five times a day, was the divine glory in each other. That notion is difficult to place in a
conventional theology. It must have been unacceptable to a segment of Rumi’s community to have
had their beloved teacher totally absorbed in the company of such a wild man. So Franklin Lewis
thinks that Shams disappeared on his own and that his tomb is elsewhere, not in Konya, maybe out
on the road toward Tabriz, in the town of Khuy. A minaret there is called by his name. Nothing is
certain. Shams shall remain elusive.
I tend to believe that the jealous murder of Shams Tabriz actually happened. One thing is sure.
With the disappearance of Shams, whether by violence or his own choice, Rumi’s poetry went
deeper. The core of longing became more radiant and vital, reflecting the depth of the communion
that was the majestic friendship between Rumi and Shams.
Rumi had two wives. The first, Gowher Khatun, by whom he had two sons, Ala al-Din and Sultan
Velad, died in 1242. Then he married Kira Khatun, by whom he had a son, Mozaffer, and a daughter,
Malika. There is a wonderful hagiographic story about Kira Khatun. One day she peered through a
slit in the door into the room where Rumi and Shams were sitting in sohbet (mystical conversation).
She saw one of the walls open and six majestic beings enter. The strangers bowed and laid flowers at
Rumi’s feet, although it was the middle of winter. They remained until the time for dawn prayers,
which they motioned for Shams to lead. He excused himself, and Rumi performed the duties. When
prayers were over, the six left through the wall. Rumi came from the chamber and, seeing his wife in
the hall, gave her the flowers, saying, “Some visitors brought these for you.”
The next day she sent her servant to the perfumers’ market with a few leaves and blossoms from
the bouquet. The perfumers were baffled, unable to identify the flowers, until a spice trader from
India recognized them as flowers that grew only in Ceylon (Sri Lanka). The servant went back with
this astonishing news, and just as he was telling it, Rumi came in and told her to take good care of the
flowers, because Indian saints had brought them from the paradise that human beings had lost. As
long as Kira Khatun lived (she died nineteen years after Rumi), the flowers stayed fresh and fragrant,
and just a single leaf applied to a diseased eye or other injured part brought instantaneous healing.
Rumi is known in the popular mind, of course, as the first whirling dervish. Shams seems to have
taught him this form of physical and auditory meditation, sema. It was called deep listening, and it
was said that whatever one was striving for would increase in sema. Rumi sometimes composed
poetry while turning. He gives several reasons for putting music and poetry and movement together
in his soul-growth work. In one of his Discourses he says: